"Health is a large word. It embraces not the body only, but the mind and spirit as well;...
and not today's pain or pleasure alone, but the whole being and outlook of a man."
~James H. West

Lisa's Blog

Think carefully about what you want, when you say "weightloss"

Lisa Cutforth - Monday, June 17, 2013

People have become "obsessed" with a number on a scale and it is such an inaccurate reflection of "physique", health, and the amount of excess fat you are carrying.

When I say to my clients, be careful with what you are doing because you could be "losing muscle" instead of fat, they don't always get just how important this is for their weight loss long term.

Muscle is the thing that sets your metabolism, so the more muscle you have, the higher your metabolism.  Also although you may not weigh that much if you have burnt fat but increased your muscle mass, you will certainly have affected your frame and your tone.  You will be physically smaller, and that's because muscle is denser than fat so takes up less fat.  It also uses up more energy so helps you get the fat off.  Whereas if you just lose weight (some muscle, some fat), as you lose fat you send your body into a stress or "scared" state which will cause it to slow down or readjust your metabolism and as you have less muscle you will burn less anyway.  Then if you start eating more again... you can actually quickly regain lost fat, and more.

I really enjoyed this comparison of two friends approach to weight loss.

"If you gained 10kg of muscle at the same time you lost 10kg of fat, you would be smaller, about 1.4 liters smaller. On the scale you would weigh the same but your pants would be looser and your metabolism would have increased so now you're burning more calories even when resting, allowing you to tolerate eating more food to stay at that same weight.

Let's say you and your friend decide to start two different weight loss programs at the same time. After 6 months, you've lost 10 kg by working out, eliminating a lot of processed foods & replacing with good healthy foods, while your friend has lost 11 kg by lying in bed drinking coffee and smoking.

Your 10kg scale weight loss might equal a 10 kg muscle gain with a 20 kg fat loss. If so, you'd be 12.3 liters smaller.

On the scale, it would look like your friend who lost 11 kg (9 kg of muscle and 2 kg of fat) was doing better, but in fact, she'd only be 10.7 liters smaller, making her 1.6 liters bigger than you and not looking nearly as good for a similar weight on the scales. Ha!

Meanwhile, going forward, who will maintain her new weight more effectively? It sure won't be your friend."

This story does oversimplify things a little but it makes an important point.  You benefit most when you exercise and eat well.  If you just restrict calories you will lose weight (and maybe faster and comparitively more than others in the short term.  But if you don't exercise your weight loss won't be sustained and you may actually regain it all. It's not just about "losing weight", if you want to keep it off, you may need to be clearer and wiser with your goal setting. 

That's why the magic formula for lasting "weight loss" is:

1. A high nutrient, low GL, low calorie diet

2. Half an hour of exercise every day

3. Doing 1 and 2 until they become habit!

Strong is the new skinny!  Remember when you set your goals, perhaps also think about numbers like:  waist circumference, dress size, jean size and not just "the number on the scale"!

Source: Ben Longley: http://www.thefoodcoach.com.au/articles/?ArticleID=1362

Post has no comments.
Post a Comment

Captcha Image

Trackback Link
Post has no trackbacks.

Recent Posts


leaky gut, gut health, symptoms of leaky gut weight allergies weight loss organic vegetables strength how to check your breasts diet diary of a nutritionist heart foundation tick explained how to get more of exercise Lactose intolerance soft drink and behavior problems hunger and stress recipes for allergies how to avoid injury during exercise drugfree alternatives fatigue do i have to drink milk; where do i get calcium from; non dairy calcium sources should I eat organic veggies gift Cancer comfort foods Dr Randy Pausch on Oprah fussy eaters high cholesterol to know and not do is not yet to know benefits of sleeping best exercise heart disease healthy fast food, healthy take away mobile phones and brain cancer, Dr Teo healthy wine, healthy beer, healthy alcohol options sexy salads seasonal quick and tasty recipes natural toothpaste healthy cooking party skip meals overindulge wrong type of exercise, exercise and results food allergies health pioneers Lisa's Diary natural alternatives to drugs benefits of strength training, why you should strength train image life choices nutritionist healthy cooking parties cheap fruit and vegetables, what's in season in autumn in australia health fun breast cancer awareness video hot guys ability to respond herbal toothpaste blood pressure diet diary cholesterol lowering diet sensitivity to milk obesity avoiding a choice christmas maintain a healthy weight, underweight foods in season, seasonal recipes homocysteine comfort eating Happiness getting fit fruit and vegetable shortage recipe immune boosting tips childrens lunch boxes feels good breast cancer prevention prostate cancer 7 steps to detox healthy shopping improve your memory libido cooking class in brisbane what is a good breakfast how to say no food sensitivities taking responsibility indigestion Laughter and stress Nina Simone addicted to chocolate love food have fun in the kitchen support your body is chocolate bad for me have more energy control the power to choose nutritionist in brisbane fresh what is movember is sugar bad dancing nutritionists diet diary cooking with allergies great second hand books recipies empty your mind low cholesterol memory anxiety 7 Tips to Lower Your Cholesterol and Protect Your Heart sugar and add immune system ways to improve prostate health low calorie meal plan new year's resolutions relationship with food nutritious four questions you must ask your doctor before taking medication skipping meals celebrate life are frozen veggies any good alzheimers I've Got Life delicious muscle wasting focus 10 % principle healthy cooking demonstration taking a break love, loneliness energy motivation weightloss sustainable living, rural development, organic gardening, rampumps, biogas go for 2 and 5 quick recipes calorie controlled diet happiness course nutritious cooking I don't get hungry muffins quick eating solutions health for busy people how to be happy health one step at a time real food quizz corporate wellness salad fun ask my doctor life fruit music simple 7 day detox plan stress, keys to managing stress, benefits of stress mood detox soft drink and behaviour problems making time to relax the tummy beast success and you food intolerances breakfast Nutritional Therapist lunch sexy salad how to love exercise comfort pig keep focused assertiveness how to avoid doing the right thing and getting the wrong results soccer, role of team sports in longevity, role of exercise and community in longevity nutrition which is better for you butter or margarine health with 10 % effort Sensational pop-eye and spinach Alan Pease make stress work for you happiness workshop benefits to keeping a diet diary reducing coffee increasing energy breast cancer awareness Add new tag relax trans fats time management and healthy living sugar and adhd low calorie diet Egg allergy what is healthy food dance gluten intolerance brain health reasons to eat foods in season fresh start healthy shopping list performance life lessons are grains healthy dangers of multitasking while you eat