"Health is a large word. It embraces not the body only, but the mind and spirit as well;...
and not today's pain or pleasure alone, but the whole being and outlook of a man."
~James H. West

Lisa's Blog

All calories are not created equal

Lisa Cutforth - Monday, June 17, 2013

Many of my clients have heard me arc up at "low calorie diets".  Here's why.

All calories are not created equal and a calorie does not give reference to the nutritional value of a food other than how much energy it "yields" in a laboratory, nor does it tell us how the body will use it. 

Just because two meals have the same amount of calories does not mean:

- They will fill you up equally

- They will satisfy you in the same way

- They will meet the same needs (nutrition, satiety or other)

- They are equally healthy

- They will be as effective at helping you lose or control your weight

- Or that they will be broken down, used or stored in the same way by the body.

The body deals with different foods differently, and an emphasis on nutrient dense (or high nutrient) (and probably "whole food") is more important than an emphasis on "low calorie", for health AND FOR WEIGHT LOSS.

A study done on two groups of people found that the people who ate more junk food, had lower nutrient levels in their blood despite eating more actual food and more calories than the other group.  So they had bigger appetites, ate more food and were less nourished than the group who ate healthier food (and were satisfied eating less).

Another study by Harvard confirmed that weight loss is not just about the amount of calories we consume but also about the type of food the calories come from:

"In a 2012 Harvard study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, 21 over- weight and obese young adults tried three different test diets—a low-fat diet, a very low-carb/high-protein diet, and a low-glycemic index diet—for four weeks at a time.

Each diet consisted of the same number of calories but differed in their protein, fat, and carbohy- drate content. In the low-glycemic index diet, participants ate carbohydrates that are digested and broken down slowly and cause a gradual rise in blood sugar levels (e.g. low-processed foods such as fiber-rich whole grains, nuts, or beans).

The result? Researchers found that the low-glycemic index diet actually speeds up metabolism and helps burn calories, making you lose weight faster, suggesting that all calories are not equal.

According to to an author of the study, David Ludwig, M.D., a professor in nutrition at the Harvard School of Public Health, “from a metabolic perspective, all calories are not alike, [and] the quality of the calories going in affects the number of calories going out.”

In other words,"Low Calorie" on it's own is not where the "magic" is. "Low calorie diet" can be ambiguous and misleading.  Calorie restriction is an effective weight control method (and in fact can also increase longevity), when done in the context of good nutrition principles. Calorie restriction should not be done ignorantly or at the expense of good nutrition, or it can actually compromise health and sabotage weight loss.

Source: Healthy Solutions to Lose Weight and Keep It Off, http://www.health.harvard.edu/


Recent Posts


how to avoid injury during exercise quick recipes healthy cooking demonstration brain health improve your memory breakfast what is a good breakfast happiness workshop comfort foods heart disease comfort pig life lessons how to avoid doing the right thing and getting the wrong results nutritionists diet diary weight loss happiness course nutritionist health for busy people quizz ask my doctor to know and not do is not yet to know strength dangers of multitasking while you eat how to be happy healthy shopping list health with 10 % effort Lisa's Diary Sensational control christmas how to love exercise four questions you must ask your doctor before taking medication muscle wasting Happiness gluten intolerance health pioneers what is healthy food breast cancer awareness memory ways to improve prostate health sustainable living, rural development, organic gardening, rampumps, biogas stress, keys to managing stress, benefits of stress benefits of sleeping image music sexy salads Nina Simone soccer, role of team sports in longevity, role of exercise and community in longevity pop-eye and spinach libido are frozen veggies any good celebrate life nutrition fatigue how to say no prostate cancer wrong type of exercise, exercise and results keep focused healthy cooking party time management and healthy living Alan Pease low calorie diet have more energy health one step at a time love food 7 steps to detox foods in season, seasonal recipes hunger and stress blood pressure ability to respond fresh start dancing Egg allergy empty your mind getting fit motivation is sugar bad maintain a healthy weight, underweight soft drink and behaviour problems cholesterol lowering diet reducing coffee have fun in the kitchen benefits to keeping a diet diary detox seasonal quick and tasty recipes trans fats how to get more of exercise diet diary nutritionist in brisbane anxiety fresh organic vegetables mobile phones and brain cancer, Dr Teo indigestion cheap fruit and vegetables, what's in season in autumn in australia best exercise immune boosting tips soft drink and behavior problems food sensitivities fun breast cancer awareness video hot guys 10 % principle fussy eaters relationship with food I've Got Life fruit performance life choices recipies the power to choose overindulge lunch sensitivity to milk reasons to eat foods in season cooking class in brisbane comfort eating assertiveness Laughter and stress I don't get hungry feels good calorie controlled diet which is better for you butter or margarine muffins are grains healthy high cholesterol mood avoiding a choice leaky gut, gut health, symptoms of leaky gut salad what is movember Cancer sexy salad food intolerances fun dance 7 Tips to Lower Your Cholesterol and Protect Your Heart simple 7 day detox plan allergies herbal toothpaste weight love, loneliness making time to relax sugar and add cooking with allergies healthy wine, healthy beer, healthy alcohol options Nutritional Therapist do i have to drink milk; where do i get calcium from; non dairy calcium sources skipping meals low calorie meal plan energy addicted to chocolate delicious corporate wellness weightloss drugfree alternatives life the tummy beast low cholesterol skip meals natural toothpaste make stress work for you increasing energy new year's resolutions healthy cooking parties focus how to check your breasts health obesity Lactose intolerance healthy fast food, healthy take away is chocolate bad for me go for 2 and 5 heart foundation tick explained great second hand books nutritious cooking immune system taking responsibility healthy shopping real food fruit and vegetable shortage recipe nutritious taking a break sugar and adhd benefits of strength training, why you should strength train should I eat organic veggies alzheimers homocysteine childrens lunch boxes natural alternatives to drugs diet diary of a nutritionist quick eating solutions Dr Randy Pausch on Oprah success and you Add new tag breast cancer prevention gift food allergies support your body recipes for allergies relax