"Health is a large word. It embraces not the body only, but the mind and spirit as well;...
and not today's pain or pleasure alone, but the whole being and outlook of a man."
~James H. West

Lisa's Blog

Butter or Margarine: Which is better for you?

Lisa Cutforth - Saturday, January 09, 2010

Which is better for you butter or margarine?

It is the age old debate, whether to choose the "less processed", purer but saturated fat of butter or the processed, trans fats from margarine.  The two schools of thought are as divided as the "Love it or Hate it" Marmite campaign, it would appear.  Until now...

Having been brought up in a family that despised margarine and wouldn't hear of the downside of butter, I definitely grew up with a taste for it, and so naturally was pleased when I was able to find all these health benefits.

Health benefits of butter:
Butter really is rich in beneficial nutrients, including antioxidants, vitamins, minerals and beneficial fatty acids.  
Butter may be protective against cancer with antioxidants like vitamin E and selenium and anti cancer agents like vitamin D and conjugated linoleic acid.    

However it is our heart health we are concerned about when avoiding butter, so let's look at the facts. 
Butter which is high in saturated fat raises cholesterol, but it actually raises the good with the bad.  Elevated cholesterol levels have been implicated in heart disease.

Dietary guidelines for saturated fat recommend no more than 10-15g a day.  One tablespoon of butter contains 7g of saturated fat, so that's a lot.

What about margarine?
Margarine on the other hand is made with plant oils and is generally unsaturated, containing more monounsaturated and polyunsaturated oils which help to reduce bad cholesterol (LDL) without raising total cholesterol.  Unsaturated fats are usually healthier and they tend to be liquid at room temperature.  When we consider margarine, it is first necessary to consider how margarine is made. 

Basically the process involves taking a generally healthy plant oil which is naturally in a liquid state and converting into a solid.  It is this process that produces the undesirable effects associated with some margarines.  Very often this process involves hydrogenation, which is the addition of hydrogen to vegetable oils to form a more "solid" fat, which makes it more spreadable and less likely to spoil (or oxidise and taste rancid).     

The problem with this hydrogenation process is that trans fats are formed.  Trans fats affect cholesterol with a double whammy, they both increase the bad cholesterol and DECREASE the good and have actually been found to make blood platelets stick together. 
One tablespoon of this type of margarine will typically give you 3g of trans fats and 2g of saturated fat.  Arguably, not actually better than butter, when you consider that butter will also increase good cholesterol.

However, now it is possible to buy margarines that are trans fat free (this may mean they contain 0.5-2g of trans fats per serve.  These are usually the ones recommended by the Heart Foundation and are found in tubs or liquids rather than in wrapped "blocks". 
(They get around adding the hydrogen by adding water in the process). 

So, when buying margarine you need to be sure you read the labels and be sure you choose varieties that read: trans fat free and no hydrogenated oils.

The Solution:

Here is what I do, which I believe gives you the best of both with the least "processing":

I mix half butter and half olive oil and make a delicious and very spreadable spread. 

The recipe:

250g good quality pure butter (no salt added)
1 cup olive oil

Leave the butter out so it becomes soft, then using a beater blend the two together until the oils are mixed and the texture is smooth.  (No need to overdo, this may lead to oxidation of the olive oil).  Turn the mixture into an airtight container and store in the fridge.  The fridge will set it so that it firms up.

Recent Posts


make stress work for you healthy fast food, healthy take away libido sustainable living, rural development, organic gardening, rampumps, biogas health pioneers how to be happy new year's resolutions four questions you must ask your doctor before taking medication control quick eating solutions 7 steps to detox recipies weight diet diary of a nutritionist ability to respond stress, keys to managing stress, benefits of stress healthy cooking party food intolerances nutritionist breast cancer awareness should I eat organic veggies Happiness improve your memory relax soft drink and behavior problems natural alternatives to drugs energy increasing energy pop-eye and spinach benefits of strength training, why you should strength train is chocolate bad for me food allergies hunger and stress health comfort eating keep focused strength low cholesterol real food music soccer, role of team sports in longevity, role of exercise and community in longevity sensitivity to milk comfort pig fun trans fats nutritious how to say no healthy wine, healthy beer, healthy alcohol options taking a break what is healthy food benefits of sleeping fresh start Sensational reducing coffee nutritionists diet diary organic vegetables breakfast gift reasons to eat foods in season are frozen veggies any good soft drink and behaviour problems breast cancer prevention have more energy ways to improve prostate health love food health with 10 % effort childrens lunch boxes heart disease gluten intolerance diet diary how to avoid injury during exercise performance Alan Pease getting fit are grains healthy fun breast cancer awareness video hot guys lunch the power to choose Lactose intolerance benefits to keeping a diet diary life choices mood high cholesterol ask my doctor fruit and vegetable shortage recipe life lessons 7 Tips to Lower Your Cholesterol and Protect Your Heart drugfree alternatives assertiveness sugar and add great second hand books low calorie meal plan dance corporate wellness heart foundation tick explained avoiding a choice Dr Randy Pausch on Oprah image focus Laughter and stress anxiety life how to check your breasts what is a good breakfast homocysteine maintain a healthy weight, underweight taking responsibility alzheimers time management and healthy living immune boosting tips making time to relax christmas nutrition delicious healthy cooking parties prostate cancer nutritionist in brisbane overindulge happiness workshop celebrate life sexy salads skipping meals fresh fussy eaters 10 % principle weightloss how to get more of exercise Cancer sexy salad seasonal quick and tasty recipes cholesterol lowering diet the tummy beast healthy shopping list do i have to drink milk; where do i get calcium from; non dairy calcium sources quick recipes Nutritional Therapist feels good blood pressure allergies to know and not do is not yet to know dangers of multitasking while you eat indigestion herbal toothpaste simple 7 day detox plan health one step at a time love, loneliness immune system brain health Nina Simone happiness course cooking with allergies memory go for 2 and 5 muffins which is better for you butter or margarine low calorie diet comfort foods I don't get hungry success and you recipes for allergies skip meals cheap fruit and vegetables, what's in season in autumn in australia healthy cooking demonstration dancing food sensitivities wrong type of exercise, exercise and results nutritious cooking relationship with food addicted to chocolate leaky gut, gut health, symptoms of leaky gut muscle wasting natural toothpaste healthy shopping I've Got Life Add new tag Egg allergy have fun in the kitchen mobile phones and brain cancer, Dr Teo motivation sugar and adhd best exercise empty your mind salad support your body calorie controlled diet is sugar bad foods in season, seasonal recipes Lisa's Diary cooking class in brisbane quizz obesity how to avoid doing the right thing and getting the wrong results how to love exercise what is movember health for busy people detox fatigue fruit weight loss